What to expect from your Auditor

One thing I encounter among my clients is that they don’t know what to expect. Accountants in general are terrible communicators; if you’ve worked with them in a client relationship, imagine what they must be like as bosses and coworkers! But seriously, my apologies. It is something I want to change in my small way.

First, the selection of the auditor is the responsibility of the board, particularly the finance/audit committee, if applicable. See this excellent National Council of Nonprofits article for more. The ED, management or other employees may have a part in the selection (or manage that continuing relationship) only at the board’s discretion. That said, with most of my clients I work 99% with the ED or finance team. But if you have comments or questions about your organization’s relationship with the auditor, you should talk to your ED or board, as applicable.

The selection process is once again best explained by a NCN article, we’re more concerned here with what you’ll be dealing with after that step. Let’s clear up some terminology:

-          Audit: technically there are audits and “attestation” engagements. Casually, they are collectively referred to as audits, which is confusing. We will use that term in the casual sense and specify when we are using “audit” as opposed to “attestation.” Likewise, the professional who performs attestations will generally be referred to as an auditor.

-          Financial statements: we generally refer to “formal financial statements” in respect to the final product of an audit, which are published financial statements with footnotes in an appropriate basis of accounting including the Independent Accountant’s Opinion Report. This is as opposed to the balance sheet and P&L you may get out of your bookkeeping software, which can also be referred to as financial statements. I am afraid there is no accepted terminology which makes this less confusing.

-          Certified Public Accountant (CPA): if you’re getting an Audit or “Review” (one of the aforementioned attestation engagements), there will a Certified Public Accountant at the top of the chain of command of the auditing team, even though you may not interact with them. Although accountants who are not CPAs can do the majority of your audit, and provide many other services, the CPA designation is still required to sign off on the opinion report on those formal financial statements.

-          Independence: Auditors must be independent in appearance and in fact. That’s why you can’t hire your uncle Chad, for starters (sorry, Chad), but it influences many aspects of the audit.

Even the limited actions of preparing the financial statements based on the underlying accounting records or preparing the 990 may be considered a threat to independence - that refers to whether you prepare your formal financial statements and footnotes, or more likely your auditor does that. But to do so, your auditor needs to identify “mitigating controls,’ most commonly “by designating an individual who possesses suitable skill, knowledge, and/or experience (SKE)” to oversee the service. That might be an ED or Finance Team member, including you, dear reader.

Your auditor is prohibited from posting transactions or making management decisions. However, it is common to make adjusting journal entries for the formal financial statements and footnotes in the course of our engagements, but at some point, you will be asked to sign off on your responsibility for them, so make sure you understand them. You may also need to post those to your own books. In some cases, the auditors may provide you with two lists – a list of Adjusting Journal Entries (which you are generally expected to post) and a list of Reclassifying Journal Entries (which you are not expected to post). When in doubt, ask your auditor.

Since Sarbanes-Oxley, your auditing firm are restricted from providing non-audit consulting services to their audit clients. However, some firms are comfortable going above and beyond the audit engagement at no extra charge. These are grey areas that each CPA firm will interpret based on their risk profile, busy schedule and profit incentive. As a champion of the nonprofit sector that values community over profits, we try to make time to teach and improve your organization to every extent possible, although there will prohibited or “out of scope” services on occasion.

You see, the prices that auditors quote in our engagement letters are fixed – up to a point. Though auditors have the ability (but not always the desire) to help with accounting and accounting-adjacent issues we uncover during our engagements, we also reserve the right to consider certain services “out of scope,” which translates to “we are going to charge extra for them.” You’re not expected to know what these are. We did not invent this term so we could surprise you with extra fees, though some firms may exploit such an opportunity. A good auditor will communicate with you if they encounter any such items, and they will provide you with an estimated cost before doing those services.

That’s a great start! We would love to hear your questions or suggestions, even your war stories. We are in this to help, and the more we know, the more we can do.

Brian Chick

A CPA who has specialized in nonprofit accounting, and serving Health and Wellness practitioners

https://mca-cpa.co
Previous
Previous

Introduction to Grant Accounting Series

Next
Next

How much does a Nonprofit Audit cost?