First of all, a note on our terminology: accountants and non-accountants alike tend to use the term “audits” as shorthand for “audits and attestations,” which also include Reviews, Compilations and other organizations, as you will see in a lot of my other blogs.
However, here we will use the term “audit” in reference to financial statement audits, with a note at the end about Reviews and Compilations to help you consider alternatives when you use our Nonprofit Audit Estimate Calculator.
Even from the inside of the accounting industry, with 15 years of auditing experience, pricing for new clients is a mystery. So if you are out there looking for answers, and not finding any, you are not alone.
To that end, Making Change Accounting (MCA), spent a great deal of time working on a pricing model for our own purposes. Since our priority is community over profit, we are making that model available to you, with the option to consult with us if you are interested in a formal proposal.
That said, my model comes with some caveats, which are listed in the Nonprofit Audit Estimate Calculator.
· This is only an estimate, not a quote.
· For a quote, the auditor will generally examine your most recent financial statements or records, and 990s. The auditor may anticipate extra costs for multiple locations, first-year audits, or complex areas such as (but not limited to) investments, leases, restricted net assets, pledges, benefit plans or endowment funds.
· Most of our experience is with organizations with less than $5 million in annual revenues and fewer than 50 employees, with most of the remainder being under twice those thresholds. The more the organization exceeds these thresholds, the more the model seems to overprice the related estimate, in our experience. We would love to hear your feedback so we can improve this model.
· In theory, an auditor audits an already existing set of financial statements and notes. In practice, auditors will frequently prepare these financial statements and notes, though it is considered a service that threatens our independence without adequate safeguards. This estimate included auditor-prepared formal financial statements and notes and the existence of those adequate safeguards. If you are capable of preparing your own financial statements, you may get a slightly lower price.
a more formal quote or proposal, CPAs generally estimate the staffing expected to be needed to complete the engagement. The firm will estimate the number of hours needed to complete the procedures and the billable rate of the staff expected to do the work. There will be a difference between those billable rates and the rates those staff are paid, which will be the firm’s overhead and expected profit, of course.
For instance, a firm might estimate that they need 10 hours of planning, 12 hours on tests of controls, 15 hours on revenues, 35 hours on balance sheet accounts and 8 hours of partner review. They might then estimate that the audit may require 80 hours of audit staff, 50 of an audit senior and 20 hours of a partner or manager at their respective rates. If you are interested in more on this topic, let us know!
For Single Audits, audited GAAP basis financial statements are required, and the quoted price includes all such required services. In other words, a single audit is an audit within an audit, the Turducken of audits. The difference between the estimator and the actual quote/proposal may be quite different, because that number can vary depending on the complexity of the grant, the organization’s history with that grant, among many other factors.
Reviews and Compilations are considered “attestation” engagements, and are not as complex or involved as a traditional audit. I don’t have an estimate calculator for such engagements, but in general:
· Reviewed Financial Statements will cost about 40-50% of the price of an audit, and
· Compiled Financial Statements will cost about 30-40% of the price of an audit.
Stay tuned, we will put out a blog post about reviews, compilations and other “attestation” engagements.
We hope that helps you set expectations at the beginning of an RFP or quote process, even if that process does not involve us – let us know how the estimator measures up to actual proposals received, because we will always be adjusting our model to better serve the nonprofits we love.