Cash, Modified Cash and GAAP

In practice, the most common bases of financial statements in the US are these three options, though there are special frameworks for special situations. But let’s pretend that those don’t exist for now.

Cash Basis – under this basis of accounting, all transactions are recorded on the timing of “cash receipts and disbursements,” and those terms will be used in lieu of “revenues and expenses.”

What that means is that the nonprofit balance sheet will generally have only one asset (cash) and one equity/net assets line, which may be called “Net Cash Balances” or something similar. Since noncash transactions are not recognized, there will be no accounts payable or receivable, no prepaid or accrued expenses, no fixed assets or related depreciation, etc.: all of these are accrual-type accounts.

The profit and loss may be called something like the “Statement of Cash Receipts and Disbursements,” for instance, and the Statement of Functional Expenses may be renamed the “Statement of Functional Cash Disbursements,” but the formats will be similar to what you are used to, if you have experience with financial statements.

Obviously, there will not be a Statement of Cash Flows, since the Statement of Cash Receipts and Disbursements will already track the change in the cash accounts.

Modified Cash Basis is just cash basis plus modifications, as the name suggests. Generally, these modifications selected should “provide a benefit or an obligation that covers multiple reporting periods,” such as the capitalization of certain fixed assets with the corresponding depreciation or investments in marketable securities acquired with cash.

The idea is that without the modifications, the financial statements will be inconsistent, misleading or unreliable, but such exceptions should be chosen judiciously. Per an AICPA practice aid, “the preparer should be prepared to defend how the decision to modify or not modify is a logical and consistent application of the accounting policy and does not result in misleading financial statements for the purposes for which they are intended,” and they make some clear exceptions, as well warning against a “free-for-all” method of preparing such financial statements that end up looking like GAAP accounting except for the titles of the financial statements and the explanations in the footnotes.

For instance, let’s say your nonprofit has a large note payable in this year, but traditionally reports on a cash basis. That note payable may be an appropriate item to modify the cash basis, but that does not mean that you should also be adding accounts payable and accrued payroll liabilities, unless their absence also makes the financial statements inconsistent, unreliable or misleading.

Depending on the modifications made, the statements may have titles similar to those of cash or GAAP statements, and they could include a statement of cash flows.

Generally Accepted Accounting Principles (GAAP) – calling this framework “accrual” or “full accrual” is just scratching the surface, because it also comes with a kazillion rules regarding footnotes and disclosures. It is the gold standard that all public financial disclosures must adhere to, which is why they are mandatory for those who require single audits, and is the most likely requirement if your state requires you to have a review or an audit.

This very rigid framework is intended to make your financial statements complete, consistent and transparent. The idea is that once you know them, you can size up any company or organization, although in practice the rules for any given industry have become so specialized that a finance professional with only modest talents is better off sticking to a niche. For nonprofit organizations, that guidance can be found Financial Accounting Standards Board (FASB) Accounting Standards Codification (ASC) Topic 958. There is no paywall, but you may need a login to view it.

And that’s all we are going to say about GAAP in this blog post, lest it becomes a book.

Now that you know a little bit about the choices:‍ ‍

What basis of accounting should you use? We would not encourage you to spend extra time, money and resources on any accounting upgrades, unless we were convinced there was a definite and measurable need or benefit. In all things, your mission should come first. Of course, it may be that your strategy dictates such a change, but that’s outside our scope of expertise. We stay in our lane, and our passion and knowledge is accounting and auditing. But if you are looking for help with strategy, we know some great professionals, do not hesitate to ask.

How does this fit together with your bookkeeping? ‍ ‍

A lot of you may be using bookkeeping software such as Quickbooks Online, which has a toggle for cash and accrual versions; although cash will correspond to cash basis financial statements and accrual loosely to GAAP, you may find your financial statements and your books do not appear to be in synch in either mode.

This may be disconcerting, but technically correct; for instance, as in our example above you could be recording a Note Payable, Accounts Payable, and Accrued Payroll, but not all of those amounts may be considered an appropriate modification for your financial statements’ basis of accounting under the modified cash basis of accounting. It certainly would be nice if there were no differences, but what matters is that an educated financial statement reader (especially your CPA) can reconcile the two.

What about your 990? ‍ ‍

Is that going to be on yet another basis of accounting altogether? We have bad news and good news. The bad news is that there may be some variances: for instance, unrealized gains and gifts-in-kind. However, the good news is very good: the 990 does not intrinsically have its own distinct basis of accounting. In practice, the organization can choose the appropriate method on the 990 that generally matches the organization's internal books and financial statements.

Conclusion:‍ ‍

As always, we at MCA are writing about what we know. If we can help you with anything in this area, do not hesitate to reach out to us. Likewise, please let us know if there is a specific nonprofit accounting topic you need to know more about.

And thank you for reading.  

Brian Chick

A CPA who has specialized in nonprofit accounting, and serving Health and Wellness practitioners

https://mca-cpa.co
Previous
Previous

How much does a Nonprofit Audit cost?

Next
Next

Single Audits